Solo Guide No. 002 · Getting started · October 2026
AI consultant or AI agency? Choose by what you need handed over.
Hire a consultant when you need a decision, an agency when you need a defined thing built, and an implementation partner when you need the deciding, the building and the running handled by one accountable team. The quickest test: ask who will decide what to build, who will build it, and who will run it after launch. Whichever of those you cannot answer from your own team is the job you are hiring for.
Why the labels confuse. They are not standard.
Nothing defines what an AI consultant or an AI agency is. One firm calls itself an agency and only advises. Another calls itself a consultant and also builds. So judge by what you receive and who runs it afterward, not by the name on the website.
AI made building cheap, which is why so many firms can now build something for you. Deciding what to build, and owning the result, did not get cheaper. That is the real difference between the three options below.
In this guide: a consultant advises and hands you a plan. An agency builds a defined project and hands it over. An implementation partner decides, builds and runs the work with you. Solo Studios is the third kind.
The three options. Side by side.
| Consultant | Agency | Implementation partner | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Good at | An independent view, ranking options, training your team | A defined project, specialist craft, working to a scope and a date | Choosing the work, building it in your tools, running it with your team |
| You receive | A written plan or recommendation | A finished build: tool, site, campaign or content | A ranked plan, then working tools in your own systems |
| Who builds it | You, or someone else you hire | The agency | The partner |
| Who runs it afterward | You | You, or a support plan if one is offered | The partner, with your team |
| Best when | You have a builder already, or need one decision | You know exactly what you want and can run it, or it needs no running | You are unsure what to build, it touches several tools, and nobody has time to run it |
| Watch for | A plan with nobody assigned to carry it out | Nobody owning the result after delivery; unclear ownership of files and accounts | A longer commitment. Ask for the minimum term and how you stop |
When each is the better fit. Including when it is not us.
- Choose a consultant whenyou want an independent view before spending, you already have an IT person, freelancer or vendor who can build, or you want your team trained.
- Choose an agency whenthe job is specific and finite, such as a new site, a campaign or a single assistant, and you can run the result yourself.
- Choose a partner whenyou are unsure what is worth building, the work touches several tools, and nobody has time to run it.
A second opinion, a tool to pick, a policy to writeConsultant
A site, a campaign, one assistant, fixed scopeAgency
Several tools, work that keeps changingPartner
Which fits you? Six questions.
It opens with sample answers so you can see a result. Change any answer, or clear them and answer your own. Nothing is sent anywhere; your answers stay in this browser.
A guide, not a verdict. If two score close, read both. Your own judgment about your business outranks any chooser.
Free
Get the next guide. Straight to your inbox.
One plain-English guide at a time, for owners of small and growing businesses. We'll email you when the next one is published.
01A worked example · Marketing
Same company, same need. Different question.
A sample home-services company wants every new lead answered within minutes. It first asked three firms "can you do AI?" and got three pitches it could not compare. Then it asked each firm who decides, who builds and who runs it afterward.
How to read it: the second round made the three answers comparable, and showed which job the company was really hiring for. Sample scenario, no real figures.
| Before | After | |
|---|---|---|
| The question | Can you do AI? | Who decides, builds, runs? |
| What came back | Three pitches | Three answers, one grid |
| Decided on | A demo and a brand | Who runs it in month three |
| Result | Stuck | A clear pick |
Five questions to ask any of them
- Who will do the work?Ask to meet the people, not only the person selling.
- What do I own at the end?Accounts, files, data and the instructions behind it. Get it in writing.
- What happens in month three?Who looks after it when the first excitement is over.
- How will we know it worked?One number, measured before and after.
- What would make you advise me not to do this?A firm that can answer is thinking about you, not the sale.
If you already hold a proposal, guide 003 shows what a good AI assessment includes and the red flags to check for.
Names and roles, not "our team"Named
Accounts, files and data are yoursIn writing
A person who looks after itOwner
One number, before and afterMeasured
They can name a case to skipCandid
Where Solo fits
Solo is a good fit when
- You run an established business that is great at its craft and stretched on everything else.
- The work touches several of the tools you already use.
- You want strategy, build and running from one team, with a senior person making the calls.
- You want one number you can watch move.
Look elsewhere when
- You need one decision or a second opinion. A consultant is the lighter choice.
- You know exactly what you want and it is a fixed project. An agency may be faster.
- You have no revenue yet. Start with a short discovery call; a lighter path may serve you better.
Everything Solo builds lives in your own tools and belongs to you.
Questions
Can one firm be more than one of these?
Yes. Many firms advise and build, and some also run the work afterward. Judge a firm by what you receive and who is accountable after launch, not by the label on its website.
Is a consultant or an agency cheaper?
It depends on the scope and on what is included. Compare what you receive and who looks after it afterward, not the headline number. A small advisory job is a lighter commitment than a build, but a plan nobody carries out costs time too.
Do I need a consultant before I hire an agency?
Not always. If you can describe the job on one page, with the goal and one number to move, you can brief an agency directly. If you cannot, spend a little on the deciding first, with anyone you trust.
What if I already have an IT person or a freelancer?
Then a consultant or a short advisory engagement may be all you need, because someone can already build it. Ask the adviser for a plan your builder can follow without them.
How do I check a firm before I sign?
Ask for a reference in a business like yours, a sample of their written work with the client details removed, and what happens if you stop. Guide 003 covers what a good assessment includes and the red flags.
Next step
Not sure which you need? Bring your six answers.
Book a discovery call with your chooser result and we will go through it with you.