Solo Guide No. 003 · Getting started · October 2026
What a good AI assessment includes. And the red flags.
A good AI assessment is a written document that ranks the work worth automating in your business, shows what each item should save or earn and how that was worked out, says what it needs from you and where a person approves, and proposes a small first project you can measure. If what you received is a list of tools, a demo, or a quote with no ranking, it is a pitch, not an assessment.
What an assessment is for. One question, answered in writing.
An assessment answers one question: where would AI pay in your business, and in what order? It should leave you able to decide, with the reasoning on the page, even if you never hire the person who wrote it.
Free or paid, the test is the contents, not the price. And a short assessment that says to build very little can be the best kind. Knowing where not to spend is a result.
Estimate: 6 hours a week, low effortStart here
Estimate: 3 hours a week, low effortNext
Estimate: 4 hours a week, medium effortLater
Estimate: 2 hours a week, low effortLater
What you should get. Eight parts.
- 1
Your goal and the number to move
States what you want in your own words and one number that shows it worked, with today's value as the baseline.
- 2
A map of how the work happens today
The repeated tasks, who does them, and which tools and data they touch. It should be drawn from your business. If it could describe any company, it was not.
- 3
A ranked list, with the scoring shown
Each use case scored on value, effort and risk, in an order you can follow. It also says what was left out and why. Guide 001 has a simple sheet to try it yourself.
- 4
Estimates with their assumptions
Every saving or gain is labeled an estimate and shows how it was worked out, such as hours a week times an hourly cost. Change one assumption and you can see how the result would move.
- 5
What it needs from you
The data and tool access required, the person on your side who owns it, and the time you will need to give.
- 6
Risks, limits and approvals
Which tasks touch customers or private data, what could go wrong, and where a person approves before anything goes out.
- 7
A small first project with a finish line
Scoped in weeks, not months, with what done looks like, how it will be measured, and when you would stop.
- 8
What you own
The document is yours. A good plan can be handed to another builder, and it says what you keep if you stop working with the author.
Red flags. One is a question. Several are an answer.
- A tool is named before the problemThe proposal opens with a product, not with what is costing you time or money.
- Savings numbers with no stated assumptionsA figure appears, but not how it was worked out.
- A guaranteed resultA promise of rankings, revenue or savings. Nobody can guarantee those.
- The same list would fit any businessNothing in it mentions your customers, your tools or your way of working.
- No mention of risks, limits or human approvalEverything is upside. Nobody is shown checking the work.
- The plan only works if you buy their buildYou cannot take the document to anyone else and use it.
- No one is named as having done the workYou cannot tell who wrote it or looked at your business.
- Pressure to sign before you have seen itA deadline to decide, or a request for payment before you see the document.
Check a proposal. Tick what it has.
It opens with a sample proposal so you can see a result. Clear it, then open the proposal you received and tick each part you can actually find and each red flag you can point to. The tool shows what is missing and writes the questions to send back. Nothing leaves this page.
Is it in the document? Tick what you find
Red flags Tick what you see
Parts found
Red flags
Tick what your proposal has.
Start with the eight parts above. The verdict updates as you go.
Questions to send back
A guide, not a grade. A short proposal for a small job may skip a part for a good reason. Ask why before you decide it is a flag.
Free
Get the next guide. Straight to your inbox.
One plain-English guide at a time, for owners of small and growing businesses. We'll email you when the next one is published.
05A worked example · Reporting
From a pitch to an assessment.
A sample service business received a one-page proposal: a tool name and a quote. It sent back four questions: what number moves, how the work was ranked, what the estimates assume, and where a person approves. The second version had the parts the first one lacked.
Read it: nothing about the business changed. The document did, and now the owner could decide on the reasoning, not the pitch. Sample scenario, no real figures.
| As received | After questions | |
|---|---|---|
| Ranked list | No | Yes |
| Assumptions shown | No | Yes |
| Who approves | Not said | Named |
| Verdict | A pitch | An assessment |
Questions to ask before you pay for one
- Who will write it,and what will they look at in my business?
- What will I have in hand,and in what form, when it is done?
- How do you rank the options,and will I see the scoring?
- What would make you tell me to build nothing?A firm that can answer is working for you.
- Can I use the plan with someone else?If not, you bought a sales step, not an assessment.
- What happens if I stop?Ask what you keep.
One you can launch in two to three weeksStep 1
Before anything is builtStep 2
Anything a customer sees, until results are steadyStep 3
Same number, same wayStep 4
Also ask to see a past assessment with the client's details removed. If the assessment ranks several items close together, start with the one that has the clearest owner on your side.
Where Solo fits
How ours works
Our assessment is the start of an engagement. A discovery call comes first, then a strategy call where we walk you through a preview of the audit. Month one holds discovery, the full audit and a ranked plan, written for your business and set out in the agreement. The plan is yours, and it is written so another team could follow it.
When you do not need us
If the right move is a small change in a tool you already own, the assessment should say so. If you only want a second opinion on a proposal you hold, a consultant may be the lighter choice. Guide 002 covers consultant, agency or partner.
Questions
How long should an AI assessment take?
It depends on the size of the business and how much access you give. Ask for a timeline up front, and be wary of one that takes months before you see anything.
Is a free AI assessment worth it?
It can be. A free preview is a fair way to see how a firm thinks. Judge it by the eight parts in this guide, and ask what the full version adds.
Should the assessment tell me which tool to buy?
Sometimes, as a result, never as the starting point. The order should be the problem, then the process, then the tool.
Who should be involved on our side?
The person who does the work, not only the owner. They know where the time goes and what a mistake costs.
What if the assessment says AI is not worth it for me?
Then it did its job. Knowing where not to spend is a result, and a firm willing to say it is worth listening to.
Next step
Got a proposal? Bring it.
Bring it to a discovery call and we'll go through the questions with you.